
The Argument features many aspects of the music community’s dream and nightmare, an album ready-made to form divides the size of the Grand Canyon, so perfectly does it epitomize everything that delights and frustrates music obsessives in equal measure. After a decade of establishing themselves as thinking, breathing, romantic writers of the post-hardcore genre that they played as large a part as any band in certainly blossoming if not birthing, MacKaye and Picciotto steer headfirst into the wonders of art rock, transplanting breakdowns with pop moments for equally transcendent release. It’s a highly enjoyable, even a mysterious listen, and one which looks good on Fugazi.
Despite not being as furious as the genre typically presents, or as excitable as previous Fugazi works, The Argument nonetheless stands as a crucial entry into the post-hardcore boom of the turn of the Millennium, fit in every way to stand alongside classics such as “Relationship Of Command” and “The Shape Of Punk To Come” as well as other albums of the time-frame which marry the atmospheric stylings of the genre to artier leanings, like “Source Tags & Codes.” The protection a fan-base feels the need to afford to the band it idolizes can be a strange matter, and any sort of split in the Fugazi ranks is rendered as perplexing as it is inevitable by the fact that they smack this one out of the park, a logical end point in their evolution of sound.
As mentioned, the characteristics of post-hardcore are channelled into a guitar album that relies on brooding, inexplicable vibes and complex melodies. The smooth, slow-moving riff of opener proper “Cashout” bubbles under the surface, seeming set to build to an all out climax that never properly arrives, over deceptively straight-forward lyrics that riot against the concept of money over morals, a bizarre option in the context, and which seem to veer between a presumably unintended tongue-in-cheek and a genuine, more Fugazi-esque hard-faced anger. There could hardly be a more appropriate track to intrigue, suck in the listener and leave a desire for more.
From there, the only crescendos are soaring rather than crushing. “Epic Problem” is a major highlight and is the track that unleashes the most ferocity, a groovy stop-start structure laying the foundation for a brilliantly poppy sing-a-long ending over a delicious, deadly strum. “Strangelight” is another track with a super-cool monster hook, providing enough satisfaction to make up for the general absence of guitar-based conclusion. The album is well summarized by the left turns of “Ex-Spectator,” where the track halts quite jarringly to give way to squirming guitar lines and a beautiful bass throb, the wondrous “Life & Limb”, which grows out across a condensed 3 minutes with a gloriously flexible riff and non-stop, dreamy vocal hooks, and the way tracks like “The Kill” and the closing “Argument” are so calm, made to bathe in their simmering and interlocking guitar-bass harmonies which never threaten to collapse from their watertight unison, either downwards into generic form or upwards into more standard, loud, discontent post-hardcore.
Yes, it’s art rock and no mistakes, a lesson in writing underground rock music with a royal subtlety and an awe-inspiring knack to bring in the listener, in the moment and for repeat listens, despite the fact that the answers are never going to be forthcoming, in terms of explaining the album’s nature. The decision to write an album like this doesn’t need so much explanation, as it only further solidifies Fugazi as masters of their craft. Some might even say that they saved the best for last.













